Bartholomewtown
Bartholomewtown is an independent news and interview podcast exploring Rhode Island through conversations with the people driving politics, culture, business, and public life. Hosted by journalist Bill Bartholomew, the show delivers insightful interviews, original reporting, and clear-eyed analysis from New England's smallest state—with stories that often resonate far beyond it.
Bartholomewtown
Dan McGowan (Boston Globe) joins Bill Bartholomew
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Boston Globe columnist and author of Rhode Map Dan McGowan joins Bill Bartholomew for a final look at the 2026 Rhode Island elections.
On election eve, the Boston Globes, Dan McGowan joins us, Dan. It is, you know, it's one of those scenarios. We wake up, or actually last night we got some new polling from the University of New Hampshire. Helena Folkes widening her lead in the governor's race. 55-34 for Ken Block, Aaron Gian at eight. Uh, we might see Aaron Goukean dip even lower. But what do you make of these numbers and and sort of where we are in general in this election season?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, um, look, you know, I sense that that I was a little surprised, admittedly, that that uh UNH has her, you know, up on 21 points. But I do feel like uh you know, she's in a position where she has a good strong chance to get uh, you know, over 50% of the vote and they potentially well over 50% of the moat. You know, this this has been, I wrote this in Ray Map this morning, and I hate to quote myself, but you know, there's been in that after the primary for Lolita Folk, and it's been a very ho-hum uh general election. But the truth isn't it she's trying to run a steady race, right? She's trying to uh east football as a you know, she's running three yards and it's not a dust, no fumbles, no mistakes, just just get through this race. Um, and you know, because we're political junkies, reporters, whatever, we want more, right? We want where's the touchdown? Where is the big, you know, where's the thing that where's the you know memorable thing? And and that campaign is thinking, just get over the finish line. That's all we have to do. Now they'd like to get over 50% of the vote. They don't want an argument when they're coming in, you know, where it where it where you could make where someone like Ken Bloc could make the argument, well, if Eric McKid wasn't in this race, um, you know, I might have won. So, you know, I'm not surprised she's jumped down to a to a lead, to a pretty healthy lead. I'm a little surprised it's that much. And then, you know, in the contrast, like the flip side, what when I think about Ken Block, and Ken Block is gonna do better than he's ever done before in any governor's race, but he is in this tough spot where I spent all of last week, it feels like, talking with you and Dan about you know campaign finance violations. He he's kind of fallen into that sort of watchdog RI traps that he that that he's always been. He's always been, you know, that kind of person, meaning, you know, somebody who's who's keeping people's eye, you know, keeping you know the eye on the public's business and that kind of thing. But does that translate into uh you know vote for governor? And I'm I you know I find it hard to believe that he's in a great space given that he's not spending a lot of money. Uh he's he he he like I said, he's you know, kind of gone down this rabbit hole on the campaign finance stuff. That's not what general election voters are thinking about. So it feels good to get lots of attention, but I'm not sure it's doing very much and the polls suggest that.
Bill BartholomewYeah, I said on lively this over the weekend that he almost needs, and it's kind of similar to John Laughlin, what Nick Mattiello did when he was facing the prospect of losing his Cranston seat to Steve Fryas back in 2018, which was a couple of minutes before a press conference, they just decided in the huddle, uh, what if we just phase out the car tax, and now all of a sudden he can walk out and say, re-elect me, we'll get rid of the car tax. Even on that sort of granular level, sure, they've got the we'll cut your electric bill in half, all that kind of stuff, but it requires a little bit of detective work to understand it. Ken hasn't been able to put forward that zinger that could grab the miscellaneous votes that could get him even close to being able to fill out um you know the gaps, if you will, in the electorate that he would need to catch folks.
SPEAKER_01You say that as well, and that's a great comparison because you know, some version of I'm gonna, you know, eliminate the cars out, Scannon King's like we haven't seen this. You know what? I I spent the last two years complaining about the Lost Show branch, understandably, so is everybody else. But, you know, I'm gonna personally uh accept it. You know, I'm gonna personally sign off on every expenditure, that kind of thing. So that is that means nothing in the grand context, but actually sounds pretty good. Um, that has not happened at all in this in this, particularly in this governor's race. I actually think the John Laughlin thing about cut your bills by 50%, that could be really catchy if John Laughlin was in a spot where he actually one was running for office that that people take close attention to, and two hack money and he type in. Like if you could really tell me that you're gonna cut my electric bill in half, uh, whether you're gonna kill it or not is a different story. I think that that would catch in this moment. But uh, the thing about Ken Block to his credit is Ken Block is not a gimmick-driven person. At least he's not a gimmick-driven person on like the policy. Uh, I think he does get a little caught up in the Campeague Finance stuff, while reasonable to complain about is just not something that resonates with his voters. Nobody, nobody believes she's a cheater. Um and so, you know, he he could have been afforded to spend maybe a little more time on something substantive. Instead, you know, he ran this campaign where he knocks everything down. You can't, you're never gonna build 20,000 walls, you're never gonna do this, you can't, you know, uh uh go in this direction. And it it's this thing where you get a lot of attention on talk radio if you can block and you you know you get to be on every show and you hear your voice. People are mostly, you know, people you talk to are mostly giving you good feedback. The problem is that, you know, you that compare you're you're you're going up against a true Goliath, a true machine. Uh the Democrats spend all their time, you know, making sure that the early vote is getting out, making sure that the mail vote is getting out. Um, and that organization, it takes a lot to defeat that organization. And then uh I'm just not sure Ped has been able to pull it off.
Bill BartholomewYeah, I guess it remains to be seen. I do think it's possible that there are a lot of Ken Block voters out there that aren't counted in the polls, and I think that there's probably a lot of Republicans, whatever's left of that 8% that Aaron Goukean has, that might on election day move in Ken's favor. It all we'll we'll see how it plays out. But uh you're right that, I mean, just on the on the ground game level, I read an article this morning, I think it was in the Providence Journal, that this is the governor's race that has seen the least it was in the Providence Journal, the least expenditures for governor, total expenses. And of course that's because you've got Aaron Gukin as the what's $2,000 just in the count right now in the race. But you would think that I don't know. You would think that in a moment a serious challenge to the democratic machine would require really like almost a co a brand new coalition where you say, hey, I'm the fif if you're Ken Block, I'm the face of this thing, but here's that Casey, here's Casey Jones, the guy people see on YouTube doing brid the engineer that does bridge critiques. We're gonna fly him in and we're gonna do a press conference on the bridge and explain to you what went wrong specifically and and and just build a coalition of outside experts or something like a team, like an organization that can become surrogates and also literally on just a ground game level spread the word way, way beyond what one uh independent guy in his his small organization can do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, where's Democrats for block? Where's Republicans from lock? Like at the organization, I don't mean the like the individuals, where's to your point, the experts of lock it? In a different world, you'd have a scenario where maybe, you know, God rest his soul, someone like Alan Hassenfeld and uh Jad Hazenwight and that kind of crowd that's like, you know, let's quasi watchdog slash good government people would, you know, would get behind. Let's, you know, let's take down the Democratic machine here. There's a real chance. Chad is not really organize that. There are people, you know, there are many of people, and there are certainly Democrats who are gonna vote for him, there are certainly Republicans who are gonna vote for him. There are definitely people in that kind of Darlene Violet watchdog crowd that are probably gonna vote for him. Um, but there hasn't ever been a formal organization. You know, I took this in roadmap today. Ken Block could end up spending less on this race than he spent in 2010 when he was the moderate party candidate, you know, just trying to keep the party on the ballot. That that's tough when you're up against somebody who has an endless amount of money, right? Linnaphone says not actually even had to tap her own bank account for this race. And she's gonna spend upwards of seven million dollars beating the primary in the general election year. Um and so it's just really, really hard to uh to be able to overcome all of that. Uh you you really needed a lot more organization and probably a lot more money uh to pull this off.
Bill BartholomewYeah, and uh a lot more presence in the digital landscape as well. That you know, obviously the the first thing you would look to locally would be David Morales and Ross Lippman and the team that they built and how that what I'm not gonna say that won the election, but it didn't hurt, that's for sure. Um, and and was a driver, and we didn't see a character um, you know, you can think of it the same way as anything wrestling or uh an NBA uh budding superstar or a a politician. It's all identifying a character and elevating that character to superstar level. And that process didn't happen online, it didn't you know he didn't jump out in a way that was like, oh, that that guy again that's constantly dropping zingers or speaking about you know why we need alternative parties, whatever the case may be, or appearing alongside Andrew Yang in ten different videos that show up in over the course of a few months. All of that kind of stuff was absent, and I was very surprised because I thought somebody would swoop in and kind of give him a hand.
SPEAKER_01Right you know, for much of the last uh 16 years in the public, like he is mostly I I say watchdog, you know, depending on the issue and depending on what you think of him or what the issue, you could say godsly. Um but try the smart, thoughtful guy who loves data. There was a win who ran a campaign, not as a personality the way David Moral's did, but to say, to retard it, hey, uh South Kingstown, your school test scores have fallen this way. Hey, Westerly, this is happening. And here's all the data to show it. He could have run a campaign like that. By the way, now it's AI, you can probably, you know, really do that in a in a cheaper and more efficient and probably more coherent way than ever before. You know, this is a guy who loves data. He loves the breakdown of you know what's happening in each city and town and those kind of things. And I think you got a little too bogged down. I mean, this is true of the media too, but you know, you know, Aaron Bukina's gonna get 8% of the mode. He occupied 50% of the time um in this race uh uh over the last couple of you know, the last six weeks, let's say. And so it's almost as though Ken Block forgot to kind of run his race. He got a little occupied on on Aaron, and then he got and he just never quite used, you know, his strengths, not being a personality, but you know, being smart. Like, show me that you're as smart as I know you are. Um, I don't know that he he was able to into success because it's a little more, it's not done quite as nasty, but uh I always say Ken Block ran an optimistic smart guy campaign in 2010, and then he ran a very negative campaign in 2014 that got kind of bought down against Alan Son. Yes, race is a lot more 2014 can block than it is 2010.
Bill BartholomewAnd that hurts him now. 2014 hurts him now. There's still, no doubt, residual distaste for block within the Republican Party, and even then now the sort of former Republican Party. Imagine a different world where I don't know, I have no idea if this is realistic, but the Fungs or a Blake Philippi, or you know, you get these sort of former Republicans that are soft Rs that have a base. Um, Philippi in South County, obviously. Obviously, you need Criston, you need Warwick, you need Providence. You can get a lot of that, as we saw in the CD2 race, uh, from a Fung parallel. So there's this coalition that exists from the right that just for some reason is so damaged that you've got Jessica De La Cruz, the House Minority Leader. Aaron Gukin purports that she told him to stay in the race. I try to track down Jessica De La Cruz to confirm that. Can't get a call back now for two weeks. They don't want to go anywhere near this guy. It just shows you that they're they're willing to crash their own party rather than say, you know what, Aaron, we're you don't have to drop out, but tomorrow morning there's gonna be a press conference. Mike Chippendale is gonna step forward, you know, General Centracchio is gonna step forward, Gary Sass is gonna step forward, Blake Flippy is gonna step forward, Dela Cruz is gonna step forward and say, enough's enough, we're behind block. The fact that that didn't happen, that's deep-rooted personal stuff.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, the fact that that didn't happen the day after the primary, right? Like he needed that to happen. This is what he got an erased invite. It's not he didn't have a long runway, but it wasn't exactly the shortest runway of all time either. Kevla needed to raise more body, he needed to really put together a coherent argument for why he should be the governor. He you were staring at a Republican primary where you had, you know, all the folds were wrong, obviously, but they showed Elaine Tolino, you know, pulling away. Imagine if Elaine Tolino was the nominee right now, right? You should have been preparing for scenarios where I know Elaine Tolino was gonna be the nominee and she was gonna give the campaign. There probably was going to be, you know, a pretty significant um uh uh you know group of people moving away from her because they because they didn't want to be associated with her campaign. Uh, but then you should have been prepared for, okay, in the scenario that Eric Duchane wins, he's gonna have no money, he's gonna be kind of a milktoast candidate. Uh, you know, we have to be ready no matter what. Um and then instead, you know, it took a little while to get a poll out that that did start the conversation about you should get out. But Aaron Duchan, classic, you know, third, even that he's the Republican, he classic third party candidate. He he decided he disliked the number two guy worse than he than he disliked the Democrat, right? And he he was emboldened and he was a thorn in Ken's side in your debate, in the Channel 12 debate, uh kind of knocked Ken Block off his game to some degree. Not that Ken performed poorly, like we shouldn't say this has been a total failure from Ken Block. He he's a he's a better candidate today than he was in 14 and 10, and he's greater better than he's ever done. Uh, but better does not eat a view in a sick in a in a system where uh you know Democrats are in a really good moment. There's the Democrats nationally are singing poised to do really well. I mean, look back four years ago, Dan Ventini got 56% of the vote in in the general election. I mean, Halita folks probably wants to be in that range uh to show I have a mandate. I'm you know I can go for it here. Um and and Democrats and independents tend to be uh you know signaling that they like the democratic leadership of the state.
Bill BartholomewAbsolutely. And that will translate to the lieutenant governor's race. Uh, in my mind, this thing has been um you know a lot further apart than what we've seen from polling or even from an anecdotal again. It it is a good race, and having moderated that debate, they're they're both good at what they do. Um, and people constantly underestimate Sabina Matos. Nobody knows that better than you, having covered Providence politics now for a zillion years. Uh you know, on a statewide basis, people underestimate Sabina Matos. Look, it is what it is. You just have to look at X and the gross commentary about her. Um, that flavor exists. That there are people who maybe it's the accent, maybe it's the Providence. I who knows what it is. But that does exist. She's up against that at some level, but nowhere near enough that John Laughlin's going to make a charge in my mind. And that you've pointed out I've been following up with the Democratic Lieutenant Governors Association who don't even have a phone number. So I'm, you know, it but trying to follow up with this organization and understand why are you putting out these blasts now for three consecutive weeks that say, hot race to Nevada, hot race here. All over the country, we've got Democratic lieutenant governors under fire from MAGA candidates, but no mention of Rhode Island. I just think that that says they realize, and you see it now, just over the weekend, there's such a joint campaigning effort between Helena and uh between the folks' campaign and Matos campaign, and between Helena and Sabina, who are taking photos together, wearing each other's t-shirts, this, that, and the other. So I don't think they're very worried in Matos headquarters about John Laughlin, but should they be?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I don't think that they're I think that they're worried because Sabina Matos has been through um tough, even if she's won tough elections, you know, multiple times. Yeah, I mean, she's pretty tested, battle tested. She didn't have a uh very competitive primary, even though she won uh significantly uh, you know, kind of going away. Uh this time in the general or in the in 2022, she had a uh, you know, a pretty decently competitive primary, though she won pretty comfortably. And she got a little scare on it on in the general election against Harry McKean in Lieutenant Governor's race by I think 10 or 9 twins, whatever it was. Um, and this goes, I mean, you know, Figueroa lost her first race ever, right? She lost the council race uh and then came back and won uh four years later and and had a great career as a, you know, in Democratic politics in Providence, definitely the council president, those kind of things. She's somebody who is a survivor. She's better at this than than people give her credit for. Um, so I think she she knows. Obviously, he had the really horrific campaign for Congress, uh, which she knows exposed some flaws in her uh strategy and messaging and all those kind of things. But she is, she is, she's talented and she's certainly not taking the race lately. I think John Buffalo has very successfully avoided for the most part the you know the label that that I think I would imagine Vamacho's campaign was looking to use, which was, you know, kind of racist Republican uh misogynist. That that's what the that's the campaign they hope to run. They'd love to run against Miller.
Bill BartholomewYeah, right.
SPEAKER_01You know, in a campaign like this. But John did a pretty disciplining job. The challenges is that, you know, he didn't get a lot of help from anybody. He didn't in the Republican Party, as you pointed out, is you know, barely existed in this one. I know they've done, I see the they do a bunch of, you know, uh images on social media. I I assume some of that went to maybe some mail and things like that. But you know, John needed a collaring message. And the the thing that I've been very surprised by, John, um, is that I thought the winning message would have been something to be effective. Let's get, you know, J. McC already got beat in the primary. Let's get, let's, let's, you know, finally cut ties with the Nickey administration, right? He was this is the hand cancel tank governor by Governor McKee. Um now obviously they tend a falling out and they're not as close as they used to be, but that the average voter doesn't know that. You couldn't have run a campaign that just said, you know what, it's time to give somebody else a chance. Let's finally cut ties with Nikki. You did it, you did that in the primary, let's do this in the general. Never really made that kind of arm commit. It was more, you know, I want to be this kind of policy-centric guy on the energy stuff, which um which I think the end results, and you know, I want to cut your energy bills by 50% is most smart. But in some of those debates, you're saying get tail 12 and chill 10, you know, they they my mind kind of whooped away when, you know, I sort of it it was kind of twisted when it starts talking about, you know, the different places that we get our energy. And that's a that's a very in-the-weeds conversation for you know 30-minute debates.
Bill BartholomewRight. And admittedly, you know, um there was that mo well, there was that moment, I think it was the first debate, the channel 10 debate where the lieutenant governor confused natural gas for gasoline. And it I don't I think at the end of the day, if you said, do you understand the difference between natural gas and gasoline? She would likely be able to tell you pretty closely, if not totally accurately. But even in the debate, I think it got a little bit lost in the weeds when I was in the room with them. You start to hear lingo in terms that you're like, uh, you know, I what's a decatherm again? I'm not I I have no idea. Right. I have no idea. I'm not gonna pretend I've ever I mean, I'm sure I've heard that term at a conference here or there. I'm sure somebody's mentioned it a million times. But for example, the and so I think that's where he gets off of of his whole energy, cut your electric bill in half. Remember the inspector general thing? Everything was very, very convoluted. And what you said right there is such a smart I have not I haven't thought of that or heard that. That's such a smart take. You run as the hey, look, we got rid of McKee. I'm not gonna even tell you who I'm I'm not worried about the governor's race. I'm endorsing anybody other than Dan McKee. I want Dan McKee out of here. Look at the Washington Bridge. You know, this isn't about politics of of party, this is about integrity, whatever it is, and he didn't run that. Maybe softly. I vaguely recall a press release that mentioned the McKee Matos administration, but not really. And that's that's exactly it. He might have actually had a shot.
SPEAKER_01His other big you do a social media campaign that you know crosses out McKee because he's already lost. He needs some, you know, something clever. Again, these people are all using AI for everything they can do. There's a total way to do this. Um maybe it wouldn't have worked. Look, again, as he said, Sabia is a a a a better, a more talented person, politician and media for credit than than anybody ever gives her credit for. And it's a blue state where where Democrats are are likely are always the favorite. But I I there could have been a way I think to um you know to run a close race. The polls have had it close until this UNH poll. You know you've been on this longer than I have but you you you've you know I think you pointed out that that that you didn't think this was this close a race as some of the Channel 12 poll, the previous uh the Sal Vergina poll had um lawfully you know I I bought into Lawland as a as this race came close. I still think this is probably the closest race we'll see um up you know up to tomorrow on election day but uh it's certainly an advantage Sabina it's very sick music.
Bill BartholomewYeah the other thing to glean from this race is it's now expanded to include Seth Magazine or another candidates as well but Sabina was the first person to appear in a video with David Morales, one of David Morales's own videos and as soon as I saw that I went wow that's calculus right there that's risk reward. We just saw polling that Morales is unpopular um in some places certainly on a statewide basis overall Aaron Gukin's out there socialism this Gene Valescente and his debate socialism coming to providence you know how's that tie into Israel on and on and so this this is a statewide cloud if you will that has been elevated in recent weeks on major platforms. And still Sabina did the video with Morales and I didn't hear I mean talk radio fallout a little bit you know a few people complaining but that seems to also be an indicator of David Morales and Providence and sort of the effort to make it you know what did Aaron Coquin say he's the most dangerous politician in America. It seems like the calculus is yeah we're just going to go ahead and ignore that on a statewide basis and Morales is going to be able to transcend the notion that he's you know this that that that Providence is going to be turned into a s a municipal experiment in socialism.
SPEAKER_01You know so that's what they see he gets votes out in Providence and they want to write up the score Lalina folks, Seth Magazine, Matos, uh you didn't see one to shard on the local cathares uh kind of partnering with with David Morales. That's they see that they think they want those first time primary voters to turn out from them in the general election. I think there's also something that that um beyond just right now it's all about politics, right? I just want the votes people are gonna have disagreement to David Morales. There is gonna be certainly someone with the Seth Mind the senior is not um you know he's much more moderate than than uh than David Morales is but you know that the thing that dawns on me is that unless you get a catastrophic first six months uh you know snowstorms go terribly crime spikes out of control and there's then there's in given there's like a dismissiveness to it unless you get those kind of things The house is gonna have a a really um significant honeymoon uh as the mayor of Providence I think you're gonna see his his popularity actually go up even more uh and in and he'll probably I don't know I you know I don't know if the socialist ran will ever help him statewide or at least in the short term help him statewide. But I think what people are discounting about about Morales is in those first couple of months as mayor he is gonna make around every nonprofit and every anything that she can speech at he will speak at every time a business group has an event every time there's people in front out of town kind of the old buddy Sancy way and that's what a green mayor does but I haven't known Dave in a long time if you have to you get the sense that he's gonna enjoy those parts of the job and and it's not just something that that Brent Smiley he didn't like it but Brent Smiley's a little stiffer he's a little he's not as you know charismatic in these things that I feel you're gonna start to hear uh a lot particularly in that nonprofit community meaning the the the the influential nonprofits the United Ways and the world you know groups like that I think you're gonna start to say you know what boy like not only did he come with his event and you know give us 20 minutes and sound great and say all the right things he actually was pretty engaged in what we care about. And I think people are going to be really impressed with uh with David Morales. That's not to say he's always gonna get it right. It's not to say that it you know that every uh that democratic socialism is going to take over Providence because it's not gonna be about democratic socialism. It's actually going to be about the human David Morales that I think people are gonna really, really light uh used to say being their providence is being a cheerleader in chief. And and you know you got lots for that a little bit because Correct Warzo was not the person cut out to do that. That's not his personality. He's not as bubbly as David Morales. That's not what it is. I think David's gonna love the cameras the the the showmanship that becomes uh that that comes with being the narrow prominence is again as long as he avoids uh you know something significantly bad happening early on which is easy to say um I think he'll I I think people are gonna really link it and so they're gonna be why I said the politicians if they think that that people like him and then we start to see Kong that suggest people like him they're gonna want to be associated with him.
Bill BartholomewYeah that's absolutely right it's gonna be almost worth keeping an eye on the naysayers if you will that that flip to not just softer like well yeah morales is fine but almost like a Siancy effect where people who are ideologically of course Siancy was a Republican turned independent but issues or ideologically opposed or they say man I can't believe Siancy was such a jerk about graffiti back in the whatever it is or obviously the corrupt aspects of his administration on and on it goes his own personal you know he can list a a a million reasons why people would personally dislike or politically dislike Buddy Syancy yet eventually it just became a he became a warm figure in the city a larger than life figure. I think Morales has a chance to almost surpass that where it's bigger than politics.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I mean I that's a really good point. Now most of the people who were around uh Buddy Siense um and who almost save in to you know submitted to to the the aura of of uh Buddy Ciancy most of them are no longer around there's maybe a few remnants of that left but it is exactly true people were willing to then get corruption like blatant corruption and they still were willing to say you know I kind of want to be associated with this guy. He's charismatic he's fun uh you know he's he he's going to take a city at least on on the surface and in those kind of things. So you're telling me that that people are gonna really you know throw David Morales uh in the trash because they don't like that he's Democratic socialist. I mean or you don't like uh you know you don't think rent control on a as a policy conversation as a rank dancer I mean that's that that seems crazy to me. Again, unless David Morales gets unless we're we're we're giving him too much credit and he gets way too bogged down in you know Palestinian flags and you know and social issues that that you know kind of sound or are divisive. You know if he if he if if he if he succumbs to God if he kind of acts like a city council but and not like a mayor I think he you know that's where you could run into some trouble. But more likely again I think he's gonna light bully fine parts of the job either people will put up in some of the policing that they don't necessarily love. People didn't like a lot of things that Ariel did. Everybody was fine we was generally fine giving that term mayor um and so yeah I I I think you know Morales does have a huge opportunity to bring people with it and if he does a good job if he does all the things that he says he's gonna do and he's charismatic and likable um he does have a chance to reshape uh the the party in a broader way and move a lot of people to the left yes I think so too I think it'll be important for policies like rent stabilization and as it runs through the likely politically aligned with Morales uh city council in that'll that's incoming including likely Providence council president Sanchez I think it's gonna be important for people to see what does rent stabilization in debate format look like in terms of what what are the breakdowns, what are the considerations what are the carve outs how does this work for Providence right now versus a well here's one academic presentation that says it doesn't work and then here's another one that says it does work.
Bill BartholomewLocalizing the issue in a real debate that was what was lacking. I wish that that had happened and I think it hurt the smiley campaign politically I think it hurt Brett politically in in general not so much his position on rent stabilization but as at least Council President Miller tells me there was never an effort to negotiate to sit down and have any kind of conversation. I wish they had just locked themselves in a room for the weekend and came out and said look we just had the uh I don't know the the Trinity Brewhouse Accords and we're we we don't have rent stabilization coming but I'm not here to tell you we don't have it coming either we've set forth this action plan it's not it's not a study later thing it's a next week we're gonna sit down get something going. Of course that would be politically unfavorable for the council and drumming up more and more discord on the issue gave David Rawls a clear lane to victory. So I think there is that as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah there I mean look there were there are a couple things that play the politics were real the council wanted two things to wanted one of two things to happen. They wanted rent stabilization to either happen or they wanted it to be such an issue that it tells uh Dave and Ross the victory. So they got one of those and that's what that that worked. So they you know the idea that they really wanted to negotiate all these things with rent smiley probably just a little bit uh there's at least uh some there's some gray area there at the same time look the the challenge that Nair Smiley had was he he would say I was too principled. I I you know I wasn't in the cave on this issue I don't believe in it and that's why I lost but I you know my head is held high that's that's been his kind of argument no the the the broader reality is it's not that they didn't want to negotiate it's that they think the council's stupid and and I'm sorry like that that is the view of a lot of people in that smiley administration they're wrong that's not critical but it it's a very type arrogant it's not the first mayor ever to think the city council is stupid right it's just that that that is in fact often the case the the the you know stupid ridiculous some version sometimes correct right like for any lords had decided to council for a lawyer. Right uh Tober is at times had this this fight Cicellini certainly did um you know Bronny was the one that would say it Brunny would just say like these guys are goofballs they want jobs they want this and and that would kind of string everybody up um that that definitely is like it's it's like somewhat condescending second floor you know the second floor is where the mayor's office is in city hall um and and you know so I I don't think that they believed that they that intellectually there was a conversation to have in terms of negotiations. Again both sides wrong right one side probably a little more political than they should have been one side uh too much looking down on the on the legislative branch of government uh and that's what you ended up with the situation that you're in now.
Bill BartholomewYeah and now months and months and months of rent increases and uncertainty about the future of the rental market um and at the end of the day we'll see what happens we'll see how this plays out in 2027 and beyond but uh I think a lot of people if they really stepped back from it would and ought to be turned off by that kind of politics and hopefully that's not where we're heading I don't and with a council and mayor aligned on policy we may actually see more things getting done um than we saw in in the previous administration that that to a certain constituency a large one of renters and and people who are facing the headwinds of the affordability crisis in Providence that's gonna be a pretty big deal on the ground in an im in an immediate sense.
SPEAKER_01And it's also you know the the thing is is whether they're gonna actually get more done or not is is is going to be that that's one conversation. The other is is it going to feel like they're getting more done and one thing that that that that social media and kind of more video uh video first focus that that uh the the incoming mayor is gonna have is gonna could be I don't know if it I it's hard to say it will definitely be but it could be um a real you know advantage of kind of this is the thing that that Nair Mamdadi has done absolutely in New York is taking the basics of government and showing you that you're doing it is um you know says something about uh people are gonna feel like he's getting more done um than than maybe he is or at least said that they felt like they were being told before that story is really important to being able to tell it and if that's new you know he remember he's speaking to he's not exclusively speaking to a new generation of voters because I think there are plenty of people who voted for him uh who who that you know have been here a long time but it's almost gonna do this kind of feel for you know I I've I'm explaining government for the first time to to a lot of people um and I think they're gonna like that uh you know as long as it goes well now the challenge for for game gay browse is going to be when something goes wrong right it's gonna be when the when someone on the council speaks out against you and it's getting a lot of attention on top radio or from the Boston Globe you know when God forbid you have your big crime kind of situation where you know just when when when things go wrong will you be as communicative right will you be able to message your way out of it while also coming up with actual real solutions. What sometimes happens with these like very talented politicians is they're really good when the conversations and the discussions and the videos are on their terms and then when when it's not on their terms it's you know it's we're gonna go in the bunker and try to figure this out. That's a challenge. David Rawls not a bad guy he just has not had a a bad day in in multiple years as an elected official uh arguably maybe his worst day came after the Globe story after the primary about um you know kind of divisiveness on on the um you know we're in the Jewish community I think he he was very upset with that story and he doesn't like hearing that conversation but if that's the worst thing that's happened to you um as a politician uh get ready buckle off because being being mayor of Providence there are there are bad things that happen all the time.
Bill BartholomewRight.
SPEAKER_01What do you make of we see right now 100 I think it was 117 votes cast already do you think we're gonna see a big turnout with the midterm or is there this presumption of well it's a blue wave it's a blue state I'm gonna stay home so my assumption is yeah we're gonna see a fairly decent uh sized turnout um I you know I always think early vote at least until I'm proven proven wrong early vote favors Democrats and so you know I'm interested to see how somebody like a Ked Walker or John Lawslane does on election day you know and and uh and nobody and I don't think you can I I don't think we I think we live in a post-COVID in a post-COVID world where you can't nobody can even make the argument oh well I won election day so you know let me imply that there was fraud or there was anything like that but I am so interested I think you know the traditional vote on election day tends to be a little more conservative to at least a little more moderate and I'm interested to see on that but I think the vapors are um you know seem to be trending in a pretty big direction shows the Democrats have you know really been able to get out their vote uh but I you know I also don't know unlike the the primary you know the primary in prominence where um you know raise my hand I I would I'd be lying to tell you if I told you given what if I thought Game Rouse was going to win when I woke up on that that Wednesday morning. That being said the as the as the numbers were coming in in the afternoon and it looked like wow turnout's gonna swell you know past 30% dinger than than the year the other than four years before um you know anyone who was who was at Smiley's uh election guy party will tell you I I wasn't a dating outer right I told all of them you're gonna lose you're it's over you lost this race uh I don't know that that turnout in the general election is a perfect predictor um so you know if you told me turnout goes 20% higher I don't know if that favors Democrats any more than I feel like Democrats were already favor. If you told me turnout was you know incredibly low I might say maybe that is to some degree you know may help someone like a John Lawson but and I don't think it's as easy to tell as as it was at least in that specific Providence primary.
Bill BartholomewElection Day in Rhode Island it is tomorrow if you're listening to this on the day we release the podcast on Monday of course follow along on the Boston Globe through the Boston Globe Rhode Island subscribe to Roadmap what's that email address if you're not subscribed you get on there Dan RInews at Globe.com if you sign me out uh if you if you send in a meeting I'll blank you know it doesn't have to say anything else I'll know when it is I'll sign you out to RInews at Globe.com. All right and just for anyone out there as well I'm sure the Globe will be covering these elections in real time and uh and obviously with recaps I'll be on uh five to six on WPRO on election night kind of bringing it home for you and then I'll be on the field I'll be at the former the formerly the Biltmore the graduate for the Democratic results party live on Instagram throughout the night at Bill Bartholomew so that is the coverage plan. This is the last episode of the podcast before this election and it feels like this has been going on for honestly ten years. It's it's it's sh it honestly feels like it's been a laborus and uphill push to get to this moment.
SPEAKER_01I don't know your thoughts on that kind of closing thoughts the the nature of this race it just feels different than any of the other elections that I've covered yeah I mean I'm looking forward to it being over it's been a long one because you know Helena Fungst has been running for governor for four years right so and so in part it is just that um it has felt long but also not exactly as exciting as as in years past. Um although you know I do wonder do we always say that I mean it's possible for you to go back and check the Tate you and I were having the same conversation four years ago and four years before that. It's possible Bill we are getting a little bit old and you know we we need a new career or something.
Bill BartholomewWe'll see we'll see Dan McGallan the Boston Globe please don't change your career at a Rhode Island and now and now global treasure m major story go read the but read McGallan's Potomac Golf course story. It's it's amazing. It's amazing. If you you probably have read it 'cause it's what it's like the most read story. Your most read story or something like that. It's good to I mean this thing has gone viral. Yeah.